The Rising Tide of Imported Goods
In Cornwall, the holiday season is marked not only by festive cheer but also a troubling trend: the proliferation of cheap imported goods being sold as genuine handmade items. Local artisans are calling for action to protect their livelihoods and maintain the authenticity of craft fairs.
The Craftsmanship vs. Commercialism Dilemma
As I delved into this matter, it became clear that many stallholders are resorting to purchasing mass-produced items online, which are later marked up and sold at local fairs. Elinor Lamond from the Cornwall Crafts Association articulated the urgent need for a vetting process: "You have to have some kind of vetting process just to keep the quality up and to spot all those little things coming in from abroad that are being passed off as genuine craft items."
"I make all mine, you've got all these customers around your table and it's all bought in." - Joanne Bailey, local crafter
Impacts on Local Artisans
Local artisans like Joanne Bailey, who creates handmade candles and soaps, are feeling the strain. At one craft fair, she noticed that shoppers were drawn to cheaper imported items rather than her craft. "There's a lot of tat people have bought and are selling at stupid prices," she lamented. The frustration among genuine craftspeople is palpable; they feel their hard work is being overshadowed by the ease of online shopping.
Organizers Respond to Protect Authenticity
Amid these issues, event organizers are implementing stricter measures to maintain the integrity of their fairs. Hannah Saint, who runs Mousehole Market, insists on a policy aiming for 85% handmade products at her events. "Some people see it as a way to make cash without having to develop any particular skills," she notes, highlighting the need to uphold quality standards.
Craft Fair Standards: What's in a Name?
Interestingly, how these events are marketed plays a significant role in the types of products showcased. Elinor Lamond points out, "The temptation is if it's not called a 'craft fair' and it's called a 'Christmas market', there's more room to bring in work that's not necessarily made in Cornwall by a craftsperson here." This differentiation emphasizes that genuine craft fairs ought to maintain higher standards than general markets.
Consumer Awareness: A Call to Action
As consumers, we also have a stake in this debate. Understanding the difference between genuine handmade goods and cheaply made imports is crucial for supporting our local artisans. Crafters like Emma Joyce remind us to look for authenticity when shopping at these markets. With communities rallying for craftsmanship, we must consider what it means to shop local and the difference it can make. It's not just about purchasing goods; it's about valuing the effort and creativity behind them.
Moving Forward
The actions being taken by Cornish crafters and event organizers could serve as a model for similar markets elsewhere grappling with the same issues. As we celebrate the festive season, let us prioritize authenticity and support those who put heart and soul into their creations. In doing so, we foster a more vibrant, trustworthy marketplace.
Source reference: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c8654eylg3vo
