Cubs' Infield Dilemma: Who's Safe After Bregman's Arrival?

Cubs Make a High-Stakes Move

Every hot stove move creates new dynamics, and the Chicago Cubs have made a major statement by securing three-time All-Star Alex Bregman to a whopping five-year, $175 million contract. This deal not only bolsters their lineup but reshapes the infield landscape in Wrigleyville.

Reported by ESPN's Jeff Passan, Bregman's contract entails $70 million in deferrals, showcasing the Cubs' commitment to a strong future. With Bregman's proven skills, the Cubs certainly aim to enhance their World Series aspirations, but the question looms: who will make room for him?

The Growing Infield Logjam

The Cubs now find themselves in a bit of a logjam. With Bregman stepping in, they have more infielders than available spots, which could lead to significant roster decisions. Notable evaluator Keith Law from The Athletic has pinpointed third baseman Matt Shaw as a likely candidate to be traded due to his inconsistent performance and perceived off-field issues.

“The Cubs now have one infielder too many, and they're going to end up trading someone,” Law noted.

Shaw, who commanded attention as the Cubs' first-round pick in the 2023 draft out of Maryland, stumbled through his rookie year, finishing with a .690 OPS, 13 home runs, and 17 steals. The Cubs may decide they need to address other positional needs or bolster the outfield—especially if they don't want to let young talent go to waste.

Continuing the Debate: Who Else Might Go?

Interestingly, Shaw isn't the sole candidate for a potential trade. Nico Hoerner, the gold-glove second baseman, is entering the final year of his current contract and could be seen as an asset worth trading. Hoerner had an impressive season, registering 6.2 bWAR and earning his second Gold Glove award.

While Shaw's more inconsistent performance gives him a clear target on his back, Hoerner's stellar contributions complicate the decision-making process. Do they opt for Hoerner's proven glove and bat or take a chance with Shaw while attempting to develop a super-utility role for him? I find myself leaning towards the latter option, given the excess talent, which can only serve the Cubs well.

Conclusion: Navigating Tough Decisions

The Cubs' front office faces a luxurious problem: having too much talent, especially in a league that often sees teams scrambling for consistent players. The challenge lies not just in deciding who might go but what the best configuration will be to ensure a championship-caliber team.

As they navigate these critical decisions, one thing is clear: Chicago's 2025 season is shaping up to be one of high expectations and potential transformations.