Introduction: The Early Season Dilemma
Two weeks into the NFL season, and we're already seeing some striking contrasts in player performances. For fantasy managers, that means it's time to evaluate which players are worth keeping or cutting based on their early-season numbers.
I've always believed that the best fantasy managers aren't those who panic at first signs of trouble; they're those who make hard decisions for the long haul.
As we navigate this early part of the season, I find myself looking closely at a group of players who have been underperforming, not just in terms of points but in terms of fantasy value and potential future upside. These aren't just disappointments — they're indicators of bigger trends or situations that need attention.
Justin Herbert: A High-Expectation Struggle
The Los Angeles Chargers' quarterback, Justin Herbert, is someone we've all been watching closely this season. With a new offensive system and high expectations from both fans and fantasy managers alike, it's clear he's still finding his rhythm.
Herbert's performance so far — scoring just 10.3 fantasy points per game with only two touchdowns — suggests that while he's not terrible, he's certainly not living up to the hype we'd hoped for. His air yards per target are surprisingly high (10.3), which might indicate a more vertical attack than expected. While his rushing numbers have dipped, that's part of the challenge when working with an evolving system.
Looking ahead, Herbert faces tough matchups against defenses like the Buffalo Bills, Seattle Seahawks, and Denver Broncos. These aren't games where we'd expect to see him put up big fantasy numbers. So for now, I'm putting him in the QB2 category — not because he's a bad player, but because his ceiling isn't what it was during the pre-season.
Colston Loveland: A Patient Wait
Chicago Bears tight end Colston Loveland has been a bit of a mystery so far. Despite having a higher volume of routes run per game (30.5), he's only managed one catch for three yards in two games.
Loveland's route tree is incredibly varied, showing depth and potential across all levels of the field — from verticals to short in-breakers and crossers. This variety suggests a versatile receiver with strong potential. However, right now, he's not seeing the ball.
The situation gets more complex as we consider the Bears' quarterback situation for Week 3. With Caleb Williams likely out and Tyson Bagent possibly not cleared for play, Case Keenum may be the backup option. In that case, I'd lean toward playing Loveland in a flex spot, just in case he sees some action. But when the team gets stability at QB, I believe he'll return to his fantasy star status — he's got the tools and track record to back it up.
Emeka Egbuka: A Player with Potential
Tampa Bay Buccaneers wide receiver Emeka Egbuka was one of my top picks heading into this season, thanks to his strong receiving traits and the aggressive throwing style of Baker Mayfield. That said, he's been underwhelming in his early performances.
Egbuka has only received 11 targets through two games, far behind other receivers on the team like Cade Otton and Ted Hurst. The Buccaneers have spread their ball around, and it hasn't been landing in Egbuka's hands yet. He's been playing in a role that isn't quite maximizing his value right now.
Still, there's a breakout potential here. With the upcoming tough matchup against Minnesota, I'm moving him down to the flex spot — but not cutting him. If he can get some opportunities and start making plays, he'll be worth keeping on your roster for weeks to come.
Marvin Harrison Jr: A Mismatch in the Offense
Arizona Cardinals wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. has been a consistent presence on the field, but his fantasy output has been disappointingly low. Despite running 29.5 routes per game, he's only seen one target in Week 2 and just three targets total in two games.
The issue here isn't just about numbers — it's about fit. Harrison is being used more as a vertical clearout than a traditional wide receiver, and the Cardinals' offense lacks the air yards needed to make that strategy work effectively. QB Jacoby Brissett averages only 6.1 air yards per attempt, which doesn't align with Harrison's route tree.
His role seems misaligned with the team's offensive plan. While Harrison is still a talented receiver, he's not seeing enough opportunities to justify keeping him in your starting lineup — especially with tough matchups looming. I'd consider cutting him for now and looking elsewhere for value.
Travis Etienne Jr: A Committee Approach
New Orleans Saints running back Travis Etienne Jr. has been one of the biggest disappointments in fantasy football so far. The team's decision to go with a committee approach rather than give him the starting role has limited his fantasy value significantly.
In Week 1, he shared carries equally with Kendre Miller (nine each), and in Week 2, Alvin Kamara saw more touches despite only producing 22 total yards. Etienne is scoring 10.9 fantasy points per game — still decent, but not enough to justify a high-end spot in your lineup.
His future with the Saints looks uncertain at best. For now, he should be viewed as a mid-tier flex option, particularly in deeper leagues where players like Kamara or Miller may have better upside. He's not a lock for a starting spot unless things change drastically within the team's offensive scheme.
DK Metcalf: Risky Boom or Bust
Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf is showing promise in terms of volume, catching at least nine targets in both games so far. But his fantasy output (7.3 PPG) doesn't match that volume.
What's troubling is the lack of big-play success — Metcalf has had five targets on throws of 20+ air yards but hasn't cashed in. That's a red flag for any boom/bust WR3 player. While Aaron Rodgers' mobility is limited and there have been protection issues, his deep ball accuracy is crucial for players like Metcalf.
However, I still see value here because of his ability to create explosive plays when he gets the chance. In deeper leagues or if Michael Pittman Jr. remains out, Metcalf can be a solid option — though it's important to monitor his usage closely.
Jadarian Price: A Shallow Leverage
Seattle Seahawks running back Jadarian Price is another player whose potential has been dampened by a split-backfield approach. He had 10 carries in Week 1, but it was George Holani who finished with more than double that number in Week 2 — despite not being on the field for the game.
Price's numbers are modest (6.4 fantasy points per game), and his receiving production is minimal (three catches on four targets). That's a concerning combination when looking at how he fits into the team's overall offensive plan.
In shallower leagues, Price is likely just a bench stash. But in deeper formats, he could be used as a touchdown-dependent RB2/flex. He's not a lock for regular playing time right now — but he does offer upside if his role changes.
Conclusion: Balancing Patience and Pragmatism
Fantasy football is all about making the right calls at the right time, especially early in the season. While we want to give players a chance to prove themselves, there comes a point where patience turns into wasted opportunity.
Early-season struggles are rarely permanent — they're often temporary misalignments between player and team dynamics or situational factors.
The key is knowing when to stick with a player and when to move on. The players discussed here are all talented individuals who may see their roles evolve as the season progresses, but for now, they're not providing enough value in their current situations to warrant a starting spot. That doesn't mean you should give up completely — just be smart about how you approach them moving forward.
Key Facts
- Primary Entity: Matt Bowen
- Article Title: Early Season Struggles: When to Panic or Patiently Wait
- Publication Date: Sep 24, 2026
- Author Role: Fantasy football and NFL writer for ESPN
- Article Category: Sports
- NFL Season Year: 2026
- Article Focus: Fantasy football player analysis and early-season disappointments
- Number of Players Analyzed: 7
Background
Matt Bowen, an ESPN fantasy football and NFL writer with NFL playing experience, examines early-season player struggles in the 2026 NFL season. He analyzes seven players who have underperformed despite high preseason expectations, providing guidance on when to cut losses versus ride the wave for fantasy managers.
Quick Answers
- Who is Matt Bowen?
- Matt Bowen is a fantasy football and NFL writer for ESPN who joined ESPN in 2015 and spent multiple years on "NFL Matchup."
- What happened to Matt Bowen's article?
- Matt Bowen's article explores early-season player disappointments in fantasy football, focusing on players like Justin Herbert, Colston Loveland, and others who have underperformed despite high expectations.
- When was Matt Bowen's article published?
- Matt Bowen's article was published on Sep 24, 2026.
- What is the main topic of Matt Bowen's article?
- The main topic of Matt Bowen's article is analyzing early-season fantasy football player disappointments and providing guidance on when to cut losses versus ride the wave for fantasy managers.
- What players did Matt Bowen analyze?
- Matt Bowen analyzed Justin Herbert, Colston Loveland, Emeka Egbuka, Marvin Harrison Jr, Travis Etienne Jr, DK Metcalf, and Jadarian Price in his article.
- What is the significance of Matt Bowen's article?
- The significance of Matt Bowen's article is that it provides fantasy managers with guidance on making difficult decisions about struggling players early in the NFL season, distinguishing between temporary misalignments and permanent issues.
- How many players did Matt Bowen analyze?
- Matt Bowen analyzed seven players in his article.
- Did Matt Bowen discuss any player strategies?
- Yes, Matt Bowen discussed various player strategies including viewing Justin Herbert as a QB2 due to tough matchups, playing Colston Loveland in flex spot if backup quarterback plays, moving Emeka Egbuka to flex spot for breakout potential, cutting Marvin Harrison Jr due to role misalignment, treating Travis Etienne Jr as mid-tier flex option, and considering DK Metcalf as boom/bust WR3 player.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Matt Bowen's background in NFL analysis?
Matt Bowen is a fantasy football and NFL writer for ESPN with NFL playing experience. He joined ESPN in 2015, writes regularly for ESPN+, and spent multiple years on "NFL Matchup."
What are the main early-season challenges discussed by Matt Bowen?
The main early-season challenges discussed by Matt Bowen involve fantasy managers having to evaluate players who are underperforming despite high preseason expectations, determining when to cut losses versus ride the wave for long-term gains.
Source reference: https://www.espn.com/fantasy/football/story/_/id/50012787/fantasy-football-rankings-trade-value-disappointments




Comments
Sign in to leave a comment
Sign InLoading comments...