Eric Karabell's Must-Grab Fantasy Picks for 2026

Introduction

As the anticipation builds for the 2026 fantasy baseball season, I couldn't be more excited to share my picks that promise to pan out. From durability to outperforming projections, these players not only bring value but a level of excitement to your fantasy rosters. Let's dive deep into the names you should keep on your radar.

Logan Webb: The Underrated Ace

Starting off my list is Logan Webb, a pitcher who hasn't perhaps gained the recognition he deserves. Despite not leading the league in wins, strikeouts, or ERA last season, he remains the epitome of reliability, leading all pitchers in starts and innings pitched. Webb embodies the unicorn of durability in an era where pitchers struggle with injuries. His consistency, coupled with a 3.22 ERA and a commendable 1.17 WHIP over the last two seasons, places him firmly on my draft board.

“Durability matters. It's about counting on a player through an entire season,” I often remind myself during drafts.

Valuable Positions: Making the Right Picks

As I sift through players, I focus on positions that could end up being league-winners. I tend to stock my team with players whose statistical reliability exceeds their average draft positions (ADP).

Catcher Choices: The Unexpected Gems

Will Smith

When it comes to the catcher position, I usually prefer to wait until the end of drafts. However, Will Smith is an exception. His elite five-category consistency rarely comes at the cost of a top-75 pick, making him a fascinating pick for those looking for a solid backstop.

Freddie Freeman: The Reliable First Baseman

Shifting gears to first base, I cannot overlook Freddie Freeman. His numbers scream consistency and reliability. It wouldn't surprise me if he ends up winning his first batting title. He remains a valuable asset when it comes to the early rounds of your draft strategy.

Second Base Surprises

I am particularly excited about Bryson Stott, who averaged 29 stolen bases over his first three seasons and hit impressively in the second half of 2025. Players like him warrant attention as they offer both speed and average.

Outfield Sluggers to Watch

When it comes to outfielders, I'm keeping my eye on Yordan Alvarez to bounce back and hit at least 30 home runs once again in 2026. His prior consistency makes him a worthy investment. Moreover, don't count out Jackson Merrill; emerging from injury, he can still provide pop and speed as a sleeper with a top-20 upside if he regains his form.

Rounding Out the Draft: Pitching Considerations

As a former pitching prospect, I always look to secure a dependable starting pitcher early. Zack Wheeler is on my radar for his capability to cross the 25-start threshold with commendable stats year-in and year-out. Meanwhile, promising youngsters like Nick Pivetta are worth monitoring. His ADP might be depressed, but the potential rewards are far too enticing to ignore.

Conclusion

While drafting for 2026, remember that combining statistical analysis with instinct is vital. Keep these players in mind as you navigate your drafts. The names mentioned could be pivotal to crafting a team that stands out and performs well through the marathon of a long fantasy season.