Evaluating the Broncos' Running Back Duo: J.K. Dobbins and RJ Harvey for 2026?

Introduction

When the Denver Broncos had J.K. Dobbins healthy, their running back room was a force to be reckoned with. Offers of elite running in between the tackles paired with RJ Harvey's finesse as a receiving threat made for an exciting offensive dynamic. However, Dobbins' injuries during the last season raise a crucial question: should the Broncos run it back or seek alternative options for 2026?

The Dobbins Effect

Dobbins was phenomenal when on the field, averaging a remarkable 5 yards per carry and had the Denver offense revolving around him. He accumulated an impressive 77.2 rushing yards per game before a hip-drop tackle dashed the season's hopes, sidelining him for the latter half.

“His injury history may suggest a gamble, but Dobbins performed as a potential top-five rusher in the league before his setback.”

This statistic highlights his immense potential, yet it raises a question: can the Broncos truly rely on his health moving forward?

RJ Harvey's Ascendancy

Drafted 60th overall in 2025, Harvey put together an impressive rookie season, amassing a respectable 206.6 fantasy points. An impressive figure among running backs in his draft range, he showcased his skills with 12 touchdowns, ranking him among legends like Clinton Portis and Alvin Kamara.

However, Harvey's rushing average of only 3.7 yards per carry indicates room for growth, particularly when faced with running between the tackles. His receiving abilities stood out, finishing 8th among running backs in receptions and receiving yards, signaling his value in a pass-heavy offense.

Contrasting Skill Sets

Dobbins brings a higher level of physicality and vision that enables him to navigate through defenses efficiently. His knack for finding holes and maintaining balance post-contact demonstrates skills that Harvey is still developing.

“While Harvey's receiving prowess shines, his effectiveness between the tackles remains less convincing.”

This difference in skill sets puts the Broncos in a difficult position. Over time, if Harvey can improve his tackling vision and glassy contact balance, he could become a valuable asset alongside Dobbins.

The Third-String Dilemma: Tyler Badie and the Others

The role of a third-string back is pivotal for any successful backfield. Tyler Badie, while decent for third-down situations, doesn't possess the same spark as Dobbins or the versatility of Harvey. With future clarity needed in the running back room, the options are limited. Badie gave about 4% of the run share in 2025. He remains a stopgap till the Broncos find a reliable source to rotate in conjunction with their lead backs.

Future Considerations

With the 2026 season on the horizon, reevaluating the running back position is imperative. The Broncos must weigh if reliance on Dobbins is wise despite his improvements in health, and whether Harvey can fill that complementary void on the ground moving forward. Will they opt to draft a more reliable presence for the backfield or trust these two to collectively lead the charge?

“To contend this next season, optimizing the running game with consistent production is the key; whether that's doubling down on Dobbins and Harvey or going for an external option remains to be seen.”

Conclusion

The Broncos are in a critical transition phase, and the decisions surrounding Dobbins and Harvey could shape their offensive identity for years to come. Will the Broncos find the right mix to take them back to playoff contention? It's a pivotal time for the organization.