Hostility and Asylum: The Unsettling Turn in Immigration Policy

The Shifting Landscape of Asylum Policies

In the past five years, as I stepped into the role of chief executive at the Refugee Council, I witnessed a transformative deterioration in the treatment of asylum seekers. The wave of hostility unleashed upon those seeking safety in the UK is disheartening, changing the very fabric of our immigration policy.

The rapid legislative hyperactivity around immigration has produced a succession of four bills governing asylum since 2020, with a fifth on the horizon, all under the oppressive narrative of control and deterrence. The asylum reforms proposed demonstrate the government's fixation on narratives that dehumanize and criminalize vulnerable populations.

The Poisonous Rhetoric

Initially, it seemed there was a slight shift in tone following the Labour government's increase in oversight, with hints of a softer language emerging. Home Office officers were urged to cease labeling asylum seekers as 'illegal arrivals.' Rather, we were led to interpret these individuals as 'irregular.' However, that change was fleeting.

Today, we find ourselves subjects of a narrative where, as Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood asserts, illegal migration is 'tearing the country apart.' This language reinforces a perception of asylum seekers, particularly single men, as threats rather than human beings in desperate need of assistance. Political discourse has never been more toxic, leveraging fear to justify inhumane treatment of migrants.

The narrative shift has emboldened the far right, giving ground for vigilante actions against vulnerable individuals.

The Unspeakable Consequences

I could never have anticipated the tragic events that unfolded—a hotel designated for asylum seekers set ablaze, incidents of violence proliferating against refugees, and relentless online attacks directed at organizations serving this community. As I prepare to step away from my role, I am deeply troubled by the aggressive undertone of hostility and violence that seems to be festering. It exemplifies the dire need for a measured, compassionate approach to immigration that has been so carelessly discarded.

Furthermore, while it's disheartening, it isn't surprising that public perception of immigration continues to sour. Despite data suggesting that net migration rates may decline, a robust majority of voters erroneously believe immigration is on the rise.

Emergency Action Required

It is paramount to recognize that legislative efforts must reflect human dignity rather than perpetuate fear and misinformation. The National Audit Office has revealed glaring realities of dysfunction within the asylum system, including staggering backlogs in decision-making. Over half of those who applied for asylum three years ago are still waiting for outcomes.

Such systemic failures should alarm everyone; the disparagement of individuals seeking refuge stems from an inability to effectively manage the processes. Confusing directives have resulted in traumatizing experiences for children, leading to life-altering decisions made under duress.

Who Are We as a Nation?

The ongoing narrative poses profound questions about our societal identity. Are we moving toward becoming a nation that embraces empathy and solidarity or one defined by fear? It requires courageous leadership to foster an environment of understanding and to counteract the divisive rhetoric that has gained traction.

As we navigate these troubled waters, we must advocate for policies that reflect compassion and humanity, understanding that refugees can positively contribute to our communities, as history shows. For decades, many have arrived in the UK seeking refuge, ultimately becoming integral parts of our society.

Conclusion: A Call to Action

As I close this chapter of my life, I implore our political leaders to break the cycle of division and fear-mongering. It's a pivotal moment; our choices will define the future of our society and the treatment of vulnerable populations.

We need collective action to uphold British values—fairness, decency, and compassion. Society must unite in speaking out against hostility and in favor of a shared humanity.