Lessons from Caerphilly: Will Labour Avoid Repeating Mistakes in Gorton and Denton?

Introduction: The Stakes in Gorton and Denton

The impending byelection in Gorton and Denton, scheduled for three weeks from now, has the potential to reshape the future of Labour. Just as all eyes were on Caerphilly, a similar spotlight now shines on these constituencies, with the political implications reverberating across the UK.

Gorton and Denton have long been considered safe Labour seats, but the political landscape is shifting. It is not only Labour's prospects at stake; the performance of their rivals, particularly the reformist Green Party, will be closely scrutinized.

Reflections from Caerphilly

As I recollect my time at the Caerphilly count on October 23, 2025, the lows of that day resonate strongly. Labour's missteps were glaring, and if history is to serve as a guide, the party must adapt or face similar repercussions in Gorton and Denton.

“Once you are no longer the best vehicle for stopping right-wing extremism, you risk losing the support of the very people who have historically backed you.”

Key Mistakes to Avoid

In examining the Caerphilly byelection, several crucial lessons emerge:

1. Failing to Communicate Value
   Labour's messaging in Caerphilly was effectively undermined by widespread local perceptions. They failed to articulate why they were still the best choice for constituents, missing an opportunity to convey shared values and community resilience.
2. Ignoring Financial Strategy
   Despite Labour's significant financial commitment, evidenced by a £98,000 spending spree, they neglected to allocate it effectively. Money alone cannot secure victory; strategy and execution are paramount.
3. Perception of Ineffectiveness
   A Labour candidate pleading for votes to save local libraries, knowing that the Labour council proposed closings, is a fundamental misalignment. How do you convince voters that you are their ally when you're part of the problem?
4. Underestimating Voter Engagement
   Turnout is critical. In a climate where voters feel their voices matter, participation spiked in Caerphilly. This must translate into strategic planning for Gorton and Denton.

The Reform Threat: A New Political Landscape

The rise of Reform and the Green Party represents a transformation in the political ecosystem. Polling suggests that the Greens may be the current frontrunners in Gorton. This underscores the urgent need for Labour to reestablish itself as the preferred alternative for those seeking to counteract right-wing movements.

A Call for Practicality and Authenticity

As constituencies like Gorton prepare to vote, Labour's survival hinges on its ability to resonate with the electorate genuinely. They cannot afford to treat voters as naive; rather, adopting a stance of accountability could chart a different course.

Looking Forward: The Path Ahead

Discontent with first-past-the-post voting is gaining traction. It's becoming increasingly clear that for voters demoralized by the political climate, a restructuring could present new opportunities for representation. Recognizing this, Labour must reconsider its approach and messaging. If Keir Starmer learns anything from the Caerphilly debacle, it should be this.

Conclusion: Does Labour Have the Will to Change?

The coming weeks will be telling for Labour. Will they learn from their Caerphilly failings before it's too late? Failure to pivot may leave the party suffocated under the collapsing facade of promises unkept and legacy forgotten.

• If you want to delve deeper into this political saga, follow my regular updates and insights on Welsh politics through my newsletter.