Mel Kiper's Top 15 NFL Draft Sleepers: Who Will Surprise Us in 2026?

Introduction to the Underrated Stars

The NFL Draft is a pivotal moment for college athletes hoping to make their mark on the professional stage. As we gear up for the 2026 NFL Draft, Mel Kiper Jr. provides his annual list of favorites: players who might not be household names but possess the grit and talent to exceed expectations at the next level.

Every year, teams prepare for the draft with rigorous scouting and film analysis, but Kiper's insights help to uncover players whose intimate knowledge of the game and passion can often be overlooked. This year, he has spotlighted players who are not merely checking boxes but bringing skills that could disrupt the status quo.

Kiper's Favorite Prospects

These are the players that have captured Kiper's attention, showcasing hard work, skill, and a passion for football that could propel them beyond their draft slots. Let's dive into fewer-known prospects making waves:

Quarterbacks

Cole Payton, North Dakota State

After working behind Cam Miller, Payton shined in his 2025 season, completing 72% of his attempts for 2,719 yards and displaying a strong arm. His mobility—running for 777 yards and scoring 13 touchdowns—could see him flourishing in an NFL sub-package role, reminiscent of a Taysom Hill style of play.

Running Backs

Emmett Johnson, Nebraska

Johnson's one-cut running style and capability as a playmaker out of the backfield make him an intriguing prospect. Racking up 1,451 yards and 12 touchdowns last season and showing his reliability in the passing game with 85 catches over the past two seasons, Johnson could easily find a home in the NFL as a three-down back.

Wide Receivers

Zachariah Branch, Georgia

Branch, a speed demon with a 4.35 time in the 40-yard dash, amassed 81 catches and 636 yards after the catch. With his versatility and playmaking ability, he projects as an immediate impact player in the NFL, likening him to Zay Flowers.

Tight Ends

Eli Raridon, Notre Dame

Raridon, at 6-foot-6, presents an enticing option in the passing game. His early-season performances showcased his ability to make critical catches and understand offensive schemes. Expected to develop into a solid role player, he could potentially ease into an NFL roster as he transitions into a more complex role.

Offensive Tackles

Max Iheanachor, Arizona State

Iheanachor's journey from soccer to football is remarkable. At 6-foot-6 and 321 pounds, he showcased exceptional athleticism with a 4.91-second 40-yard dash. His potential is massive, and teams could be looking to draft him in the second round.

Defensive Standouts

Gabe Jacas, Illinois

Jacas proves his worth by excelling in multiple roles on defense, showing versatility and production that belies the expectations for a player at his position. He racked up 11 sacks in his last season, a promising sign of his potential to make a difference in the NFL.

Conclusion: Looking Ahead

As we countdown to the draft, keep an eye on these underrated athletes who might just outperform their draft slot and become household names in the years to come. It's always the unexpected players who often leave a lasting impact on teams.