Miami's Dilemma: Should They Re-Sign or Walk Away from Darren Waller?

The Dolphins' Free Agency Conundrum

The Miami Dolphins are entering a critical phase as free agency looms on March 13, 2026. With nearly half of the roster set to hit the market, opinions are divided on what the team should do with tight end Darren Waller. At 33, his on-field presence is unique, but concerns over injuries raise necessary questions.

A Review of Waller's Performance

Joining Miami post-retirement in 2025, Waller was initially a game-changer. Despite starting strong, injuries curtailed his contributions. He finished the season with 24 catches for 283 yards and 6 touchdowns, showcasing flashes of brilliance that reminded us of his past prowess.

Injury History

Waller's stint was marred by persistent injuries, which included a hip issue and groin problems landing him on injured reserve.

“Injuries kept his impact from being a season-long event.”

Upcoming Decisions

The Miami Dolphins are facing an organizational overhaul, especially after wide receiver Tyreek Hill was released. Under new head coach Jeff Hafley, Waller could be used strategically—if he decides to return. Expectations are high, and the application of Waller's role will be pivotal.

The Options: Walk, Tag, or Re-Sign?

• Walk: The Dolphins may opt to let Waller go entirely. The focus will shift towards acquiring younger talent that fits their future strategy.
• Franchise Tag: While not the optimal choice for Waller at this stage in his career, the franchise tag could ensure immediate stability for the tight end position.
• Re-Sign: A low-risk one-year deal might provide Waller the chance to prove he can remain healthy and contribute effectively.

As I evaluate these options, my competitive instincts urge me to lean towards re-signing Waller—given that he could fulfill a critical role, especially in red-zone scenarios. However, the organization's broader strategy must take precedence.

The Broader Implications for Miami

How this decision affects Miami's draft strategy is crucial. The Dolphins are eyeing a fresh start, and Waller's age could conflict with their long-term vision. But considering the immediate need for experienced players who can make plays and mentor younger guys could keep him in the running.

In any case, the Dolphins need to make a decision that aligns with the team's trajectory—whether that means relying on Waller's experience or opening up space for new talent.

Conclusion

This offseason, the Miami Dolphins stand at a crossroads. With 35 players entering free agency, their moves will shape the franchise's future. How they handle Darren Waller's contract will set the tone for their upcoming campaign. I invite you to weigh in on this dilemma—should they invest one more year in Waller or look to the draft and beyond?

Vote here and share your thoughts!