MLB: The Elite Shortstops Shaping the 2026 Season

Introduction

In the heart of baseball's action, shortstops occupy a unique territory. Beyond just the numbers, what defines a great shortstop, especially as we approach the 2026 MLB season? The challenge lies in balancing offensive output with defensive prowess — a delicate dance that separates the elite from the rest.

MLB Network's “The Shredder” presents a comprehensive ranking of the top ten shortstops, utilizing advanced metrics to evaluate both recent performances and historical significance. Let's explore these standout players and what their skills mean for their teams and the game as a whole.

10. Zach Neto (Angels)

Stats to know: 26 HR, 26 SB (2025).

Neto's ranking at number ten on both The Shredder's list and Brian Kenny's personal rankings speaks volumes. His early-career dual-threat ability provides the Angels with a much-needed spark in their lineup. It's a compelling start for someone who is rapidly emerging as a key player in Los Angeles.

9. Elly De La Cruz (Reds)

De La Cruz checks in at number nine on this coveted list, a nod to his game-changing toolkit. Even when he's not at his peak, he exerts such pressure on defenses that it alters game dynamics. This kind of impact keeps him firmly entrenched in elite conversations for shortstops.

8. Jeremy Peña (Astros)

Stats to know: .840 OPS (2025).

Peña's entry into the Top 10 is not merely a coincidence; it signifies a consistent level of performance expected from someone wearing the Astros uniform. His contributions blend beautifully with their strategy, showing how vital shortstops can be in high-stakes moments.

7. Trea Turner (Nationals)

Turner's consistency throughout his career keeps him relevant in today's evolving shortstop landscape. Ranking seventh, he demonstrates that a solid foundation in both offense and defense is invaluable. His skill set is becoming rarer as younger stars emerge.

6. Geraldo Perdomo (Diamondbacks)

Stats to know: 20 HR, 7.1 FanGraphs WAR (2025).

Perdomo's advancement to sixth position is a testament to his complete game. His surge in offensive production, matched with solid defensive stats, places him in conversations reserved for baseball's elite.

5. Mookie Betts (Dodgers)

Stats to know: 21 Outs Above Average, 17 Defensive Runs Saved.

Betts demonstrates why he deserves a second consecutive slotted ranking in the top five, proving that even when transitioning positions, adaptability is key. His defensive skills support the argument for integrating star players directly into pivotal positions.

4. Gunnar Henderson (Orioles)

Staying relevant in the top four demonstrates Henderson's elite stature. His comprehensive skill set reflects both offensive and defensive attributes that radiate value throughout the game.

3. Francisco Lindor (Mets)

Lindor continues to show why he's a consensus pick for the top three, with reliability at shortstop being a defining characteristic of his career. The depth at this position reinforces how necessary players with such consistency are for championship aspirations.

2. Corey Seager (Rangers)

Seager's second place ranking highlights his stability in a turbulent league. Players who can maintain their position amid fast turnover are invaluable, and signing him as a cornerstone for the Rangers was a smart strategic move.

1. Bobby Witt Jr. (Royals)

Stats to know: Led MLB in hits for the second straight season.

Witt's ascension to the number one spot showcases his extraordinary talent. His remarkable back-to-back seasons leading the league in hits affirm his status and ability to impact games significantly.

Conclusion: Where Do We Go from Here?

As we reflect on these rankings, it's essential to remember that while they hold significance, it's the actual performance on the field that will ultimately define a player's legacy. The skills and talent on display in this list should translate into exciting gameplay as the 2026 MLB season unfolds.

For the complete rankings and analysis, check out the original piece on The Big Lead.