Myles Garrett's Absence: What It Means for the Browns

The Big Question: Where is Myles Garrett?

Myles Garrett, the reigning NFL Defensive Player of the Year, is once again missing from the Cleveland Browns' voluntary OTAs, raising eyebrows throughout the league. This is a critical juncture for the Browns as they embrace new leadership under Todd Monken, who was introduced as head coach on February 3. While some might see this as just another offseason fluke, I can't help but feel that it carries heavier undertones about the star's commitment to this new era.

The Tense Introduction

In a press interaction that caught the attention of many, Monken candidly revealed that he has yet to meet Garrett face-to-face. Instead, their communication has been limited to brief text messages, leaving many to speculate about the relationship dynamics between one of the league's most prominent defensive figures and a brand new head coach.

“I wish they were here. They'll be ready. We expect them to be ready and we'll be fired up when they're here,” Monken noted, emphasizing the voluntary nature of the OTAs.

That may sound all well and good, but it raises the question—what happens if this absence turns into something more entrenched? Something that no longer feels like a mere offseason absence but a more profound rift?

Context: Garrett's Past and Future

Let's rewind for just a moment.

• 🏈 During his tenure with the Browns, Garrett has both shined and struggled, garnering attention with his record-setting performance in the 2026 season where he captured the single-season sack record with 23 sacks.
• 🏈 Yet, despite the accolades—like winning the AP Defensive Player of the Year for the second time in three years—Cleveland's successes have not mirrored his individual prowess with a disappointing five wins last season.
• 🏈 Coupled with his public request for a trade back in February 2025 and a subsequent contract restructure that appears to make it easier for the Browns to deal him, the tension is palpable.

The Stakes Involved

Now, Monken has taken over a real hot seat. Not only must he navigate the waters of team culture, but he has to manage the expectations that come with a superstar like Garrett—someone whose mood can heavily influence the locker room and, ultimately, the season's outcome.

A Turning Point?

Garrett's absence isn't just about missing practice; it's a litmus test for both the player and the franchise. Myles Garrett stands at the center of a critical moment—a decision that may ultimately define not only his career but the future of the franchise he has represented since being drafted as the number one overall pick in 2017.

Our very own Mary Kay Cabot at Cleveland.com offered insightful coverage on this as she underscored the idea that the Browns can't afford to overlook the situation. If Monken's remarks indicate anything, it's that he—in his first major test as head coach—understands the weight of the situation.

Should Fans Be Concerned?

Fans are left to ponder: should we be worried? Given that scattered players traditionally don't signal the best of omens, Garrett's absence is particularly concerning in a franchise that hasn't seen substantial success. However, keeping in mind the voluntary nature of OTAs can help ease those concerns. Players are expected to arrive when they are able, but be cautious—history has shown that these situations can evolve quickly.

Looking Forward

As we all know, the NFL is nothing if not dynamic. Monken may emerge as the miracle worker the Browns need, or we may find ourselves discussing another Garrett trade request sooner rather than later. While the hope is that the season unfolds with promise, the continuing absence of the face of the franchise could send the Browns spiraling into uncertainty once more.

A Call to Action

The question now hangs in the air—will Myles Garrett show up when it counts, or will he continue to stay distant as his future with the franchise looms large? As fans, all we can do is sit back and watch closely, holding our collective breath in anticipation for the next chapter of this unfolding drama.