The Oscar Race: A Closer Look at This Year's Contenders
As we inch closer to the Academy Awards, it's important to evaluate the films poised to capture the coveted Best Picture nominations. This year's frontrunners—One Battle After Another, Sinners, Hamnet, Marty Supreme, and Sentimental Value, are nearly guaranteed to be nominated. But what about the films that sit on the fringes, waiting for their moment in the spotlight?
Why Only Five?
Recently, while mingling at a party in Los Angeles, I found myself engaged in a conversation about this year's offerings. A seasoned awards strategist shook his head as I queried him about potential nominees. “Are there even ten movies this year that are good enough for best picture?” he lamented, capturing a sentiment many appear to share. Yet, I maintain that the cinematic offerings this year include hidden gems and engaging films worth considering.
“I have seen a great number of outstanding films during this awards season,” I countered. “Independent productions such as Rebuilding, Lurker, and Urchin are remarkable examples.”
However, within the traditional Oscar framework, a few films that initially seemed promising encountered lukewarm receptions at film festivals. Take, for instance, the underwhelming performances of “The Smashing Machine” and “Roofman.” These films had been expected to shine but instead fell flat, leading to a scarcity of credible contenders.
Peering into the Crystal Ball
As Apple throws its weight behind “F1” with eye-catching ads, we must ask ourselves: Who will emerge victorious from this oscillating pool of nominees? The presumed front-runners, including
- One Battle After Another: A poignant narrative wrapped in Paul Thomas Anderson's brilliant direction.
- Sinners: With something to say and the talents of Ryan Coogler behind it, this film packs a punch.
- Hamnet: The emotional heft of this artwork will surely tug the Academy's heartstrings.
- Sentimental Value: A film that marries ambition and execution, despite its mixed reviews.
- Marty Supreme: Timothée Chalamet's performance could mean this film's ascent to the top.
However, after these five strong candidates, the landscape becomes murky. Franchises like “Wicked: For Good” or “Avatar: Fire and Ash,” despite their previous heights, might not shine as brightly this time. The mixed responses signal a shift in sentiment, marking a departure from the days when sequels dominated the awards race.
Rising Stars and Underdogs
Netflix's competition is another twist in this already convoluted race. Although they bring four films to the table, none emerge as definitive favorites. Guillermo del Toro's Frankenstein holds promise with both audacity and artistry, while Kathryn Bigelow's A House of Dynamite teases thrills but needs to deliver on the night.
Industry buzz is slowly shifting towards the quieter contenders. The subdued yet evocative Train Dreams appears to be gaining traction, quietly amassing support from voters. It represents the kind of heartfelt storytelling that often sways the Academy.
Looking Beyond the Conventional
In recent years, we have witnessed an expansion in nominations for international films. Will It Was Just an Accident by Jafar Panahi break through the barriers and stake its claim? Hailing from a filmmaker celebrated for his artistic narrative, this film exudes potential. Moreover, “Sentimental Value” stands strategically positioned to make waves.
As the days draw nearer to the awards, I can't help but throw my chips in with the more whimsical contenders. Weapons and its unexpected mixture of horror and charm bring an exciting new energy that may catch Oscar voters off guard. Who wouldn't relish a good underdog story swirled in a bit of levity?
Final Thoughts
I'll leave you with this: As we approach the unveiling of the nominees, it's clear this Oscar season is ripe with unpredictable twists. Strong contenders may outshine the murky waters behind them, but that doesn't always mean the most deserving will make the cut. Let's embrace this exhilarating yet nerve-wracking journey leading up to the big night! I'm excited to see how this unfolds.
Source reference: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/03/movies/best-picture-oscar-sinners-one-battle-after-another.html




