Re-Signing Key Players: The 49ers' Game Plan for 2026

The Free Agency Landscape for the 49ers

With the new league year set to kick off on March 11, the San Francisco 49ers find themselves navigating a pivotal moment. Out of the 28 players entering free agency, 21 are unrestricted, meaning they can negotiate with any team. In a league that changes with the snap of a finger, these decisions will shape not only the next season but the long-term future of the franchise.

Top Re-sign Candidates

While it's impossible to retain everyone, I've identified seven players who deserve another season in the red and gold. Let's explore what each brings to the table and why the 49ers should consider re-signing them.

1. WR Jauan Jennings

Jauan Jennings is more than just the leading wide receiver; he's a vital part of the team's emotional core. Despite a dip in numbers in 2025, with 643 receiving yards and nine touchdowns, Jennings remains a player who can change the course of a game. At 29, he's entering a crucial stage where stability is key. The injuries he's faced may lower his market value—an opportunity for the 49ers to show they believe in him and secure his services for the future.

2. K Eddy Pineiro

In discussions around re-signing key players, kicker Eddy Pineiro should be at the top of the list. His remarkable success rate of 96.6% made him not just reliable, but a standout in a season rife with pressure. After two inconsistent years leading up to his arrival, Pineiro's steady performance offers the kind of stability that every team craves in their kicking game. Neglecting to pen a contract with him would be a mistake the 49ers cannot afford to make.

3. DL Kalia Davis (RFA)

Kalia Davis may not be the first name that jumps to mind, but extending this young defensive lineman could prove wise. He played more games this season than in his previous two combined, highlighting his development and resilience. Given the depth concerns on the defensive front, retaining Davis as a quality depth piece could provide the 49ers with the stability they need.

4. TE Jake Tonges (RFA)

With George Kittle's future now a bit uncertain due to his Achilles injury, the re-signing of Jake Tonges makes perfect sense. His strong performance this past season shows he can step up when needed, putting up 293 yards and five touchdowns. Having Tonges as that insurance option allows the 49ers to maintain their offensive depth.

5. OL Spencer Burford

Spencer Burford proved to be a reliable depth player in 2025, though his contract shouldn't break the bank. His adaptability to play multiple offensive line positions is invaluable, especially as the 49ers look to strengthen their offensive front. He can be a bridge to more significant upgrades down the line.

6. WR Skyy Moore

Re-signing Skyy Moore isn't strictly about need; it's about tactical advantage. His special teams prowess changed games, illustrating that sometimes impact is measured in ways that stats may not capture. Keeping him ensures that the 49ers can maintain their edge in special teams while evaluating other offensive assets.

7. DL Jordan Elliott

Finally, there's Jordan Elliott, whose future may be clouded by age and cost as a rotational player. However, his experience could be crucial. While the cost-benefit analysis may lean toward not re-signing him, having him around can provide a beneficial blend of experience and youthful exuberance alongside emerging talents like CJ West and Alfred Collins.

A Balanced Approach to Free Agency

The 49ers need to adopt a balanced approach: retaining core players while also addressing gaps with strategic signings from outside. Each of these seven has shown promise and grit, embodying the 49ers' tenacity. Investing in moments of change often pays dividends in the unpredictable landscape of the NFL.

The Future Looks Bright

If all goes according to plan, the decisions the 49ers make during this off-season could spell success not just for 2026, but for the coming years. As loyal fans, we have plenty to be excited about, and it's up to the management to harness this potential effectively. After all, these players are not just contracts; they're part of a legacy we all passionately share.