Rookie RBs of 2025: Are They Living Up to the Hype?

The 2025 Rookie Running Back Class: A Game Changer?

As the NFL season unfolds, the 2025 rookie running back class is creating a buzz that analysts predicted during the draft cycle. With teams spending significant capital—25 running backs were selected, including four in the top 40—many are asking: have these rookies fulfilled the pre-draft hype?

Breaking Down the Stars

In this special feature, we'll dissect the performances of five standout rookies: Ashton Jeanty, Quinshon Judkins, Omarion Hampton, Jacory Croskey-Merritt, and Cam Skattebo. Let's delve deeper into their statistics and the challenges they face on the field.

Ashton Jeanty: The Early Favorite

Drafted in the first round as the sixth overall pick by the Las Vegas Raiders, Jeanty has garnered significant attention. Currently leading all rookie running backs with 349 rushing yards and two touchdowns over 82 carries, he possesses an average of 4.3 yards per attempt. However, he hasn't escaped criticism; his Expected Points Added (EPA) per rush sits at -0.18, which ranks him 26th among qualifying players.

Jeanty's performances have been a rollercoaster; he has showcased flashes of brilliance but also dealt with a struggling offensive line. Against the Bears in Week 4, he managed 138 yards, but many of his 26 carries for no gain or negative yards highlight an ongoing issue with his team's line execution. Despite these hurdles, the potential remains high as the Raiders work to optimize their offense around him.

Quinshon Judkins: The Stealthy Playmaker

Selected in the second round by the Cleveland Browns, Judkins has shown his capability despite a shaky start influenced by offseason issues. With 347 rushing yards and a notable average of 4.8 yards per carry, he's displayed the ability to create big plays, evidenced by his 32-yard run against the Vikings.

Judkins' play style showcases a distinctive balance—he often bounces outside and eludes defenders, reminiscent of players like Saquon Barkley. However, he too faces challenges: inconsistent blocking from his offensive line has been a common theme, as seen during his early carries where he faced overwhelming defensive pressure.

Omarion Hampton: The Rising Star

Hampton, drafted 22nd overall by the Los Angeles Chargers, initially impressed before suffering an ankle injury that sidelined him. With 314 yards and an average of 4.8 yards on 66 attempts prior to his injury, Hampton was emerging as a viable back, showing explosive speed and tackle-breaking ability that made him a crowd favorite.

His next step will be crucial; not only will he need to return to form, but he must maintain his productivity, particularly if he wants to secure a long-term role in a backfield that now shows more parity as carries are shared among other backs.

Jacory Croskey-Merritt: The Hidden Gem

Croskey-Merritt, the seventh-round selection for the Washington Commanders, has quietly risen through the ranks with impressive efficiency. He leads all rookie backs in EPA per rush at 0.18 and boasts a success rate of 60.5%. While not the lead back, his work-rate illustrates a player who can maximally exploit limited carries.

His efficiency makes him a valuable asset to the Commanders, who can utilize him in various gameplay scenarios, though the team's trust in his ability to perform regularly on third downs remains a limiting factor for Croskey-Merritt.

Cam Skattebo: The Fighter

Drafted 105th overall by the New York Giants, Skattebo's transition to the NFL has been rocky. He's accumulated 240 rushing yards at only 3.8 yards per carry, struggling with physical defenders. Although some glimpses of talent appear, such as his potential as a receiving back, his effectiveness has yet to translate consistently.

Fans are still awaiting his breakout moment, but the need for stronger performances looms large as he battles for tangible opportunities over a season characterized by injuries and coaching decisions around playcalling.

The Road Ahead

With the season still young, assessing the 2025 rookie RB class reminds us that expectations should evolve. The pressures of the NFL amplify challenges for young players, highlighting the importance of growth, patience, and development within a cohesive system.