Introduction: A Surprising Condition
Naomi Fletcher delves into the current state of the Conservative Party, a once-dominant force in British politics now facing an unprecedented crisis. It's a statement few would have anticipated but one that encapsulates the urgency of the situation: Britain badly needs a grown-up party of the centre right.
The Rise and Fall of the Tories
The Conservative party, often touted as the 'natural party of government,' has long commanded significant influence. Yet its legacy is now marred by accusations of fostering inequality and prioritizing market supremacy over the welfare of its citizens. For decades, it has steered the country's political and economic landscape; now, with its popularity dwindling to just 16%, we must ask: What went wrong?
“We may miss them if they are replaced with something worse.”
Kemi Badenoch: A Controversial Leader
Kemi Badenoch emerged as a central figure during the Conservative Party conference in Manchester. Her speeches, seen by many as aligning with hardline ideologies, have likened her policies to those of the controversial figures within the populist right, such as Nigel Farage. She represents not merely a continuation of traditional Conservative values but a possible deviation into something more extreme.
This realignment raises questions about the core identity and future positioning of the party. Will the Tories be able to reclaim their moderate roots, or are they leaning increasingly into a far-right narrative that can only lead to their downfall?
The Voices of Dissent
Within the tides of change, there exists a faction of one-nation Conservatives advocating for a return to moderation, social liberalism, and a pragmatically balanced approach. Figures like Michael Heseltine and other moderate voices highlight the party's moral obligation to counter extremist ideologies. They stress the importance of resisting the allure of populism while striving for relevance in a rapidly changing political landscape.
The Perils of Mimicking Populism
Prof Robert Ford cautions against the perils of chasing far-right populism, citing that history shows no successful centre-right party has thrived by imitating these extremes. Badenoch's proposals — from immigration policies resembling Trump's immigration enforcement to considering the dismantling of key climate regulations — run the risk of alienating the very base the party needs to survive.
A Call for Authenticity
The shifting landscapes of political alliances and media narratives necessitate self-reflection within Conservative ranks. The guardians of traditional Conservative values must identify and articulate their principles clearly to sway the disillusioned electorate and regain trust.
The Future: A Shifting Landscape
As discussions escalate about the potential for a new generation of Conservative leadership to emerge — one that honors the party's historical legacy while adapting to modern-day challenges — questions abound: will this revival be sufficient? Can leaders like Cody Butler advocate for a return to the core tenets of conservatism without succumbing to the toxic allure of extremist rhetoric?
Conclusion: An Urgent Crossroad
The Tories stand on a precipice, confronted by their past and challenged by their future. The question remains: can they realign their vision to placate a diverse electorate while protecting the values they once stood for? The stakes are high, not merely for the Conservative party, but for the entire political fabric of Britain.
This article critiques the present state and future directions of the Conservative party amidst a divisive political climate.
Source reference: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/oct/07/tory-party-britain-kemi-badenoch-one-nation
