What Happens When We Stop Talking and Start Acting?
Every year, the United Nations General Assembly fills New York with the sound of global declarations. World leaders gather to set goals, to make commitments, to say they care. But what happens when those words are just that—words? That's where Memphis steps in.
I've spent years working in cities like this one, watching how public problems don't disappear just because someone has a good idea or a catchy slogan. Real change comes from something more enduring: the slow, deliberate work of institutions learning to trust each other.
"The work in Memphis shows what progress looks like before it becomes a story."
This is exactly what I learned while visiting Memphis again and again over the years. It's not just about having the right plan or enough money—it's about building relationships, sharing data, and holding each other accountable for results.
From Kindergarten to Community Power
Memphis is a city that knows how to turn small wins into big shifts. When I first visited in 2018, there was a crisis looming over pre-K education. A federal grant was about to expire, and 1,000 seats were at risk of disappearing forever.
Seeding Success, a local nonprofit, stepped up. They worked with the city government, county leaders, funders, and providers to not only preserve those seats but expand access. Together, they raised nearly $90 million in public funding over six years.
This wasn't easy. There were disagreements, delays, setbacks. But there was also something more important: a shared understanding that kids matter—and so do the systems that support them.
The Backbone of Progress
We've all heard about “collective impact,” right? It's become a buzzword in policy circles and social innovation spaces. But what makes it real is the backbone organization—someone or something that holds the structure together when things get messy.
In Memphis, that backbone was Seeding Success. They weren't trying to be heroes—they were helping institutions figure out how to work better together. They managed data, coordinated activities, aligned funding, and made sure everyone stayed focused on the outcomes that really mattered: kindergarten readiness, early childhood development, and community investment.
And it worked. In less than a decade, kindergarten readiness among local pre-K students jumped from 34% to 62%. That's not just statistics—it's real-life progress for families who have seen their children thrive in school and beyond.
UN Goals Without Implementation Are Just Promises
This is the point where the world leaders at the UN General Assembly should be paying attention. They're good at setting goals—they're not so good at delivering them.
The Sustainable Development Goals are ambitious, but they're also vulnerable to the same challenges that affect every complex policy effort: coordination failures, lack of funding, and leadership changes that disrupt continuity.
As Garance Choko points out, only 36% of SDG targets with sufficient data are on track or making moderate progress. That's a sobering reality when you consider how much potential there is to improve lives through better education, health care, housing, and employment opportunities.
So what separates those successful initiatives from the ones that fade away? It's not political ideology or shared values—it's the willingness to collaborate across institutions, even when they don't always agree on everything else.
The Secret Ingredient: Persistence
There's no magic formula for collective impact. No single playbook that guarantees results. What matters most is persistence—holding fast to shared objectives long after the cameras leave and the headlines move on.
In Memphis, we saw this play out over more than a decade. The system didn't collapse when budgets ran low or leadership changed. Instead, it adapted, evolved, and kept moving forward because people believed in something bigger than themselves.
That belief was what made StriveTogether, the national network that supports place-based partnerships like Memphis, so effective. They reported that 71% of communities with sufficient data improved at least four outcomes against a 2022 baseline—from kindergarten readiness through employment. That's not just a number—it's proof that working together matters.
Why the U.N. Should Listen to Memphis
So what would the United Nations learn from the folks in Memphis? For starters, they need to invest more in the structures that make collaboration possible—not just in declarations or speeches but in actual funding and staffing.
The Resident Coordinator system within the U.N. has been a vital backbone since 2019. But as Garance Choko reminds us, those offices still need adequate and predictable financing to do their job properly.
At the end of the day, the U.N. talks about how important it is to act together, but it often forgets that the most meaningful partnerships happen at the local level—and they require constant effort and resources.
A 'We' That Actually Works
The work in Memphis teaches us something powerful: that change isn't about having the same vision or belief system. It's about showing up, keeping commitments, and working through differences when they arise.
Progress is messy. Institutions have competing priorities. People have different ideas of what justice looks like. But if we can build relationships that last beyond a single term, beyond a single election cycle, then we can create systems that truly serve everyone.
In Memphis, this “we” isn't driven by politics—it's driven by a commitment to children and families who deserve better than empty promises. And while the world may be full of grandiose speeches in New York, it's still possible to find hope in the quiet persistence of communities that refuse to give up.
That kind of “we” is what makes progress real—and it's something every city, every country, and every institution should aspire to.
Key Facts
- Kindergarten readiness rate in Memphis: Rose from 34% to 62% in less than a decade
- Federal grant expiration risk: 1,000 pre-K seats were at risk of disappearing in 2018
- Public funding secured: Approximately $90 million in public funding over six years
- Backbone organization: Seeding Success was the backbone organization for Memphis pre-K initiative
- SDG targets on track: Only 36% of SDG targets with sufficient data are on track or making moderate progress
- Communities with improved outcomes: 71% of communities with sufficient data improved at least four outcomes against a 2022 baseline
- UN Resident Coordinator system established: Established in 2019
- UN Resident Coordinator system funding: Needs adequate and predictable financing to do their job properly
Background
The article discusses how Memphis has demonstrated effective collaborative governance through a sustained pre-K education initiative that improved kindergarten readiness rates from 34% to 62% over less than a decade. This success was achieved through the work of Seeding Success, a local backbone organization that coordinated various institutions and secured public funding for the program. The piece contrasts this ground-level progress with the United Nations' tendency to make promises without implementation, particularly regarding the Sustainable Development Goals. The author argues that while world leaders gather in New York for UN General Assembly meetings, real change happens quietly through persistent institutional collaboration on the ground.
Quick Answers
- What is the kindergarten readiness rate in Memphis?
- Kindergarten readiness among local pre-K students rose from 34% to 62% in less than a decade.
- When were 1,000 pre-K seats at risk in Memphis?
- In 2018, when a federal Preschool Development Grant was due to expire, 1,000 pre-K seats were at risk.
- Who is Garance Choko?
- Garance Choko is the founder and CEO of Coda Societies, an M/WBE-certified strategic advisory firm working with nonprofits, governments, foundations, and cultural institutions.
- What was the role of Seeding Success in Memphis?
- Seeding Success was the backbone organization that worked with city and county governments, providers, and funders to preserve and expand pre-K seats in Memphis.
- How much public funding was secured for Memphis pre-K program?
- Together, they helped secure approximately $90 million in public funding over six years for the Memphis pre-K program.
- What percentage of SDG targets are on track?
- Only 36% of the Sustainable Development Goal targets with sufficient data are on track or making moderate progress.
- What is the significance of collective impact?
- Collective impact enables institutions to act together without requiring a shared political worldview, allowing different groups to work toward common outcomes despite disagreements.
- How does the UN compare to Memphis in terms of implementation?
- The United Nations makes grand declarations but often lacks proper funding and structures for implementation, while Memphis demonstrates real change through persistent collaboration on the ground.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the significance of Memphis's pre-K program?
Memphis's pre-K program demonstrates that collaborative governance can improve kindergarten readiness from 34% to 62% in less than a decade through sustained institutional partnerships.
How did Seeding Success help with the pre-K initiative?
Seeding Success worked with city and county governments, providers, and funders to preserve 1,000 pre-K seats that were at risk when a federal grant expired in 2018.
What is the UN Resident Coordinator system?
The UN Resident Coordinator system has been a vital backbone since 2019, bringing agencies together at the country level to translate global goals into national action.
Why are most SDG targets not on track?
Most SDG targets are not on track due to coordination failures, lack of funding, leadership changes that disrupt continuity, and insufficient implementation structures.
What is the main lesson from Memphis's approach?
The main lesson is that real progress requires persistent collaboration across institutions, shared accountability, and dedicated backbone organizations to maintain momentum through leadership changes.
How does collective impact work in practice?
Collective impact works by establishing a common agenda, shared measurement, coordinated activities, continuous communication, and a backbone organization that holds the collaboration together.
Source reference: https://www.newsweek.com/what-memphis-knows-that-the-general-assembly-forgets-opinion-12473808





Comments
Sign in to leave a comment
Sign InLoading comments...