Unraveling 'Train Dreams'
When laborers die tragically in the woods of Clint Bentley's Train Dreams, their colleagues honor them with a powerful gesture—nailing their boots to slender trees, ensuring they are remembered. This poignant scene encapsulates the film's exploration of mortality and memory, threading through the unremarkable life of Robert Grainier (played beautifully by Joel Edgerton).
Set in the early 20th century, this adaptation of Denis Johnson's acclaimed novella intricately captures the essence of a life often overlooked. Although Robert's life is seemingly mundane—building railroads and navigating his modest existence—the film reveals the profound beauty nestled within the ordinary.
“In conveying his small life, the book— and now the film—gives us the whole world.”
Cinematography as Storytelling
One of the film's triumphs is its stunning cinematography, courtesy of Adolpho Veloso. The Pacific Northwest is not just a backdrop, but a character in its own right, showcasing breathtaking landscapes that range from lush forests to stark mountains. This visual storytelling speaks volumes about Robert's internal struggles and triumphs, illustrating how the environment mirrors his emotional landscape.
As Robert witnesses a series of harrowing and beautiful moments, we are beckoned to examine life from different vantage points. The film's use of perspective—both literal and metaphorical—adds layers to the narrative. Various heights symbolize different stages of understanding and reflection, prompting us to explore the grand arc of our lives.
Memory and Reflection
The film's pacing aligns beautifully with Johnson's novella, allowing us to explore Robert's life as a series of poignant memories. Each transition offers insight into how past experiences shape our present realities. As we delve deeper into his psyche, we're left to ponder the weight of moments that seem trivial yet profoundly impact our perceptions and choices.
Edgerton: A Masterful Performance
Edgerton's portrayal of Robert is exceptional—capturing a spectrum of emotions with understated grace. His past roles may have overlooked his depth, but here, he fully embodies a man wrestling with grief, love, and the complexity of existence. Like his performance in Loving, Edgerton delivers a nuanced portrayal that resonates with the audience, inviting us to feel every twist and turn of Robert's journey.
Love and Loss in 'Train Dreams'
Robert's meeting with Gladys (Felicity Jones) brings a transformative shift to his life. Their burgeoning relationship encapsulates the heart of the film—a yearning for connection amid the harsh realities of labor and survival. As they try to build a life together while he grapples with his responsibilities, we see the interplay between love and personal sacrifice.
Exploring Humanity
Through Robert's interactions with characters like Arn Peeples (William H. Macy), we see more than just a story of labor; we witness humanity in its myriad forms. These encounters invite reflection on our relationships and how they shape our experiences, encouraging viewers to extract beauty from hardship.
Conclusion: The Art of Perspective
Ultimately, Train Dreams challenges us to reconsider our views on what constitutes a meaningful life. The boots nailed to trees serve as a powerful reminder of our transience, but also of the connections we forge along the way. As Robert looks back on his life, we are reminded that understanding often comes from stepping back—to see the broader tapestry of existence. Just as cinema can elevate the smallest of narratives, Bentley's adaptation urges us to recognize and celebrate the poetic in the mundane.
Train Dreams
Rated PG-13, 1 hour 42 minutes. Available to stream on Netflix.
Source reference: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/20/movies/train-dreams-review.html
