Unpacking the Greatness: MLB's Top 10 First Basemen for 2026

The Evolution of First Base in MLB

Spring is a time of renewal in Major League Baseball, as teams shake off the winter rust and prepare for the grueling season ahead. The anticipation in camp is palpable, with each player eager to prove their worth. As fans, we relish these moments, not just for the celebration of the game but also for understanding the evolving narratives of each position. Among these, first base has seen significant shifts over the years, setting the stage for an exciting 2026 season.

ESPN's Buster Olney recently released his top 10 rankings of first basemen, showcasing both established giants and rising stars in the league. This ranking is particularly fascinating, as it not only highlights personal achievements but also their impact on the teams and fans alike. In this column, we'll explore Olney's insights, highlighting players, stats, and the undercurrents shaping the future of first base.

1. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. — Toronto Blue Jays

The young sensation, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., clinches the top spot in Olney's ranking, and for good reason. After a stellar postseason performance last year, where he hit an awe-inspiring .397 with eight homers in 18 games, he has proven he can rise to the occasion when it matters most. His evolution from a promising prospect to perhaps the most dangerous hitter in baseball has been compelling to witness.

“He has transformed his approach, focusing on the pitcher rather than mechanics, and it has paid dividends,” says Olney. “His presence in the lineup means fireworks every time he steps up to bat.”

2. Matt Olson — Atlanta Braves

Next in line is Matt Olson, whose consistent performance has kept him relevant among baseball's elite. With a robust career trailing only a few home runs away from the coveted 300-mark, his stability in the Braves lineup is crucial. He blends offensive prowess with defensive skills, leading the first basemen in defensive runs saved last season.

Olson's ability to perform under pressure and his intent to contribute significantly in 2026 will be pivotal for Atlanta's chances.

3. Nick Kurtz — Oakland Athletics

Then comes Nick Kurtz, the A's standout rookie who caught everyone by surprise last season. Drafted fourth overall in 2024, Kurtz unleashed a phenomenal performance with 36 homers and an OPS+ of 173. His success wasn't just a flash in the pan; he displayed a maturity and skillset that belied his youth.

“When you see a rookie hit the ground running like that, it's rare,” notes Olney. “Kurtz's potential and raw talent position him as the future of first base in Oakland and potentially the league.”

4. Pete Alonso — Baltimore Orioles

Moving into the ranks, we find Pete Alonso, whose reputation precedes him. Alonso's consistency is undeniable—hitting at least 34 home runs in every year except for the COVID-shortened 2020 season underlines his reliability. Yet, the narrative surrounding him has often shifted towards his defensive and baserunning abilities, which some critics see as weaknesses.

Through it all, Alonso produced highly, which raises the question: Can he maintain this level of efficiency amidst evolving expectations?

5. Freddie Freeman — Los Angeles Dodgers

In the fifth spot, we have veteran Freddie Freeman. Though experiencing the twilight years of his career, Freeman continues to defy age barriers, maintaining an impressive .295 batting average last year. His blend of experience and emerging talent positions him as a cornerstone for the Dodgers as they chase a deeper playoff run.

6. Bryce Harper — Philadelphia Phillies

Bryce Harper finds himself in the sixth position despite fluctuating narratives about his production. His OPS+ of 129 highlights his ability to contribute meaningfully. With a fluctuating role, this season will determine if he can rise to the occasion and lead the Phillies to success while maintaining his individual record.

7. Josh Naylor — Seattle Mariners

Josh Naylor made an impressive splash after his trade to Seattle, not just as a contributor but as a force during the AL Championship Series. His ability to step up when the lights are brightest adds depth to his value as a first basemen. Can Naylor build on this momentum in 2026?

8. Rafael Devers — San Francisco Giants

Rounding out the rankings is Rafael Devers, a player whose hitting prowess is unquestioned. However, questions remain about how he adapts to a new environment with Oracle Park's unique challenges. The change of scenery could redefine his career trajectory moving forward.

Honorable Mentions

• Michael Busch — Chicago Cubs: Busch's adaptability at Wrigley is worth noting, and he played a key role in keeping the Cubs competitive.
• Vinnie Pasquantino — Kansas City Royals: After overcoming injury challenges, Pasquantino rounded out a solid season, representing the bright future of the Royals.

Conclusion: The Narrative Continues

As we scrutinize the rankings of MLB's first basemen for 2026, it's essential to appreciate that these athletes are not just mere statistics; they carry the dreams and expectations of their fans. Each player mentioned possesses a story rich in merit, legacy, and potential impact. Olney's assessment provides a thrilling glimpse into the grand theater that is baseball, but as any fan knows, the narrative is never static.

As we gear up for another season, I'm excited to see how these rankings will play out on the field, which narratives will unfold, and which new stars will emerge in the timeless game we all love.